Monday, April 15, 2013

REVIEW: Ghost in the Shell


Ghost in the Shell (manga)
Ghost in the Shell (manga)
Originally published in 1989
·         The print that came for America is notably mirrored so that it is read from left to right rather than right to left for the sake of Western readers.
·         The first chapter is done completely in color with some of chapter two done in color, which contrasts heavily with the cheap black and white print manga is used to.
·         The comic is mostly centered around a female cyborg agent named Major Motoko Kusanagi though very lightly as usually the comic goes onto be social commentary on the status of the future Japan and how robotics have changed the outlook of humanity.
·         The comic can be extremely pornographic along with violent at the time, as with the example of several ladies playing with each other’s private parts below the waist (Chapter 3, Page 5 or Page 56).
·         As a futuristic manga, the setting is surprisingly contemporary save for the fact that people have implants to become cyborgs. This is prevalent with the cityscape as seen on Page 4 at the beginning narration. This is a huge contrast with a series like Astro Boy or Battle Angel Alita where human geography changed in order to accommodate the future look like adding a flying city or making entire steam-punk slums where the destitute of humanity live.
·         Major Motoko is notably lighthearted in the manga series (like on Chapter 3, Page 38 or 89) where she almost gets herself killed yet exchanges witty banter with her battalion. This is a huge contrast to how she is depicted in the anime.
·         They go onto define future terms in articles in the manga, like robots as with Chapter 4, Page 1 or Page 98)
·         Turning women into attractive robots seem to be a more common theme than turning men into more anatomically appealing men, as with the case of Chapter 6, Page 32 or Page 141)
·         Makoto does not get her iconic costume in the anime until Chapter 7, as up to this point she had less revealing battle armor for most of her depictions.
·         Normal women are rarely seen in the manga and in their place men commonly have love doll cyborgs and clones of women they killed.
·         Makoto is in a relationship and is a strong independent woman as established in Chapter 8.
·         They don’t take the name of the series into account until Chapter 9 where a scientist places his dying mind into a robot girl’s body to live indefinitely
·         The manga is more self-contained in its original setting where Makoto is seemingly killed off yet cheats death by putting her brain into another robot body.
·         Overall, the manga is okay but the “death” of Makoto makes the entirety of the series a very self-contained story: where Makoto cannot return to her old body after the events of accidently shooting one guy, leaving her previous life behind as she merges with a Zen AI thing. It was an okay read but the variations of the anime series makes the series a lot different with each incarnation.
Bibliography:
Shirow, Masamune, Frederik L. Schodt, and Toren Smith. The Ghost in the Shell. New York: Kodansha Comics, 2009. Print.

No comments:

Post a Comment